Few cocktails on the planet carry as much history and quiet elegance as the Old Fashioned. With nothing more than bourbon, sugar, bitters, and orange, it’s a drink that strips mixology down to its essence – the spirit itself, with zero blemish. Every choice of bourbon changes the character of the glass, transforming what seems simple into something endlessly nuanced.
Regardless of what your choice is – a rich, velvety sipper or a bold, spice-driven pour, this guide breaks down the top bourbons to craft the perfect Old Fashioned, along with tips for flavor balance, pairing, and why some bottles are simply irreplaceable.
Why the Bourbon Matters So Much
The crafting of a proper glass of Old Fashioned is truly an art form, and yes, I know everyone calls everything an art form these days, but a true-to-spirit crafted glass of Old Fashioned truly belongs in the cocktail hall of fame and an art gallery.
Making an Old Fashioned is all about restraint and respect for the bourbon. There’s no citrus juice, no syrups, and no sodas, just bourbon, sugar, bitters, and ice. That means every layer of flavor comes from your whiskey.
Every stir, every cube of ice, and every aromatic twist of citrus has a role to play. This isn’t just about mixing ingredients; it’s about showcasing the heart of bourbon itself. That’s why the bottle you choose dictates everything from aroma to aftertaste, from warmth to memory.
A great bourbon for making the ultimate Old Fashioned cocktail must:
- Hold its structure against the sweetness of the sugar cube.
- Marry well with bitters (especially Angostura or orange bitters).
- Deliver a smooth finish that makes you want another sip.
Pick a bourbon that’s too young, and it tastes harsh. Pick one that’s too sweet, and it turns syrupy. The best bourbon bottles strike a perfect middle ground that ensures that they are bold yet balanced, and rich yet refreshing.
Premium Picks for the Ultimate Old Fashioned
If you are crafting an Old Fashioned meant to impress, start with these bourbons that offer beautiful complexity, smoothness, and refined character.
Blanton’s Single Barrel Bourbon
Blanton’s Single Barrel Bourbon delivers precision and depth like few others. It’s vanilla, nutmeg, and caramel tones balance beautifully with bitters and orange peel. The single-barrel nature adds uniqueness to each pour.
Plus, no two bottles are exactly alike, meaning your Old Fashioned will always have a personal touch, no matter how many times you use this bourbon for your Old Fashioned.
Weller’s Special Reserve
Weller Special Reserve brings a softer, wheat-driven sweetness that shines in cocktails. Instead of sharp spice, it leans toward honey, toffee, and butterscotch, therefore, creating an Old Fashioned that’s mellow and approachable without losing body.
Elijah Craig Small Batch
For those who want a balance between classic heat and rounded sweetness. Elijah Craig Small Batch nails it. The oak and vanilla tones pair effortlessly with bitters, and it carries enough proof to stand up to melting ice without losing character.
Woodford Reserve Kentucky Straight Bourbon
A timeless staple and bartender favorite, Woodford Reserve offers layered notes of cocoa, dried fruit, and spice. It’s a polished, elegant bourbon that makes every Old Fashioned feel like a special occasion.
Affordable Bottles That Punch Above Their Price
You don’t always have to spend big to enjoy a great Old Fashioned. Some bourbons deliver premium flavor at a fraction of the price, making them perfect for casual nights or experimenting with variations.
Buffalo Trace
Smooth, balanced, and incredibly versatile, Buffalo Trace has long been a favorite among bartenders. Its blend of caramel, brown sugar, and light spice complements the cocktail's sweetness perfectly.
Four Roses Small Batch
This is a wonderful choice for those who prefer fruity and floral notes. Four Roses Small Batch creates a light yet flavorful Old Fashioned that’s perfect for sipping before dinner.
Maker’s Mark
Smooth, accessible, and reliable, Maker’s Mark delivers a mellow sweetness ideal for new bourbon drinkers. Pair it with an orange twist and a dash of Angostura for a comforting, crowd-pleasing cocktail.
Recipe & Tasting Notes
Once you have chosen your bourbon, balance becomes the magic ingredient.
Classic Old Fashioned Recipe:
- 2 oz bourbon
- 1 sugar cube (or ½ tsp simple syrup)
- 2-3 dashes Angostura bitters
- Orange peel
- Ice
Steps:
- Muddle the sugar and bitters in a glass (use a sugar cube for texture).
- Add bourbon and stir until the sugar dissolves.
- Drop in ice cubes (preferably large blocks).
- Express the orange peel over the glass, rim it, and drop it in.
Tasting Tips by Bourbon Type:
- Wheated bourbons like Weller or Maker’s Mark create softer, sweeter cocktails.
- High-rye bourbons like Bulleit or Four Roses introduce spice and bite, making it great for colder evenings.
- Single-barrel expressions like Blanton’s highlight nuance, making each drink feel artisanal and distinct.
If you prefer a slightly bolder version, try substituting Angostura with orange bitters and adding a single dash of chocolate bitters, as this pairs beautifully with bourbons like Elijah Craig or Woodford Reserve.
Pairing Your Old Fashioned
A well-made Old Fashioned deserves thoughtful pairings. Here’s how to elevate your sipping experience:
- Dark chocolate or candied orange enhances caramel and vanilla tones.
- Smoked almonds or pecans add savory contrast.
- Charcuterie or mild cheeses (like Gouda or Brie) play beautifully with oak and spice.
If you are planning a dinner pairing, try serving your Old Fashioned alongside grilled steak, BBQ ribs, or even smoky plant-based dishes – anything that benefits from bourbon’s caramelized edge works great.
Finding Your Signature Style
Here’s a simple way to choose your bourbon based on what kind of Old Fashioned you love:
- For richness and depth: Blanton’s or Elijah Craig
- For smooth sweetness: Weller’s or Maker’s Mark
- For spice and energy: Four Roses or Buffalo Trace
- For elegance and balance: Woodford Reserve
Don’t be shy to experiment with garnishes; for instance, you can add a cherry for indulgence, a lemon twist for brightness, or even smoked cinnamon for flair. Every small tweak personalizes the drink to your taste.
Where to Buy the Best Bourbons Online
You can find all the bourbons mentioned above, as well as more premium picks, directly at YouBooze.com. Explore our full bourbon collection to discover limited editions and curated bottles suited for any Old Fashioned enthusiast.
From small-batch releases to legendary labels, YouBooze’s lineup helps you refine your home bar with quality that matches your craft.
Final Pour
The Old Fashioned might be simple, but it is never basic. Every bottle of bourbon tells a different story, and finding the right one for your palate turns this timeless drink into a personal signature.
A sip of Blanton’s brings polished precision, while Woodford whispers of dark fruit and oak sophistication. The fun lies in exploration; learning which bottle matches your mood, the season, or even the company you keep. Whether you lean toward smooth and sweet or gold and fiery, every Old Fashioned becomes a reflection of taste, time, and craftsmanship.
So, we say, go ahead and pick your bourbon, polish your glass, and let tradition meet your own taste.